Forgive the delay, I had to spend the last day and a half immersed in an ethnic conflict paper before I could move on to intergalactic conflict. But this week’s episodes were worth the wait. First up we have another recap, but this time done more interestingly and with an actual impact on the larger story. Then it’s the infamous episode 18: Pineapple Salad. But it’s not a complete downer, as there are plenty of exciting developments during these episodes to help us swallow the bitter ending. Beginning this week, Hikaru sits unconscious, recovering from his wounds after being rescued at the end of the last episode…
Lacerations, head trauma, and several hours in the water later.
This part of the dream/hallucination sets up the interesting part of the recap episode. Hikaru chases Minmay through his disjointed memories in an attempt to save her from Commander Britai, or so it appears to his unconscious mind.
It’s such a complete recap, they even recap the opening animation and song!
I know, there’s a whole bridge full of better women.
I’ll gladly accept more Armored VF-1, even if it’s just a flashback.
Hikaru chases after Minmay in an attempt to rescue her, jumping from one memory to another with odd hallucinations in between. Some of the scenes play out just as they happened, some differently, and in some cases the other characters are aware that Hikaru is dreaming and offer to help him along. After reliving his crash during the initial attack on South Ataria Island, Hikaru is teased by the PA for crashing so many times, which happens again as he tried to ride off into space on a bicycle. Eventually he meets up with Misa, Max, and Kakizaki who offer to help him rescue Minmay. Jumping immediately to their recon mission with the Cats Eye, Hikaru sits both in his VF-1 and in the back seat of the Cats Eye before skipping ahead to the interior of the Zentradi base where he sees Minmay on a floating island held by Britai. But as he approaches, Britai turns into Kaifun. Hikaru says that he’d give up being a soldier to be with Minmay, ‘killing’ Kaifun/Britai and sending him off to another altered memory.
True friends.
Not many people can pull off cute in a spacesuit.
The not-so-Little Prince.
Kaifun says a lot of things, none of which should be listened to.
The true face of the enemy.
This needs to happen to the real Kaifun.
As Hikaru’s VF-1 morphs into his stunt plane, Hikaru and Minmay are brought back to the memory of crash landing inside the Macross after its first space fold. The two camp out below decks, and discuss how busy and distant Minmay is becoming as they embark on different paths. Here the ‘marriage ceremony’ scene plays out a little differently, with Hikaru’s subconscious expressing its doubts about Minmay when Hikaru doesn’t take her suggestion to get married as serious. Then, as they were about to kiss as in the past the scene suddenly shifts to Hikaru’s kiss with Misa in front of the Zentradi commanders. He’s puzzled as to why Minmay turned into Misa, and then she says that he’s a soldier after all.
He’s come to know her well.
From crazy to sweet. His subconscious has good taste.
One of us! One of us! Also, OTP! OTP!
Waking up from his trauma induced journey of realization, Hikaru receives some visitors. First Misa comes to visit with flowers for the injured pilot and apologizes for her actions putting Hikaru in such danger. He shrugs it off, saying it wouldn’t have been a problem if he were a better pilot. The two exchange friendly shots about how Hikaru has never heard Misa say ‘sorry’ and Misa never hearing Hikaru use the words ‘thank you’ before Misa has to return to the bridge. Once there, Claudia wants to know all the details, and advises Misa to go after Hikaru, even if he’s younger. Soon after that Roy, Max, and Kakizaki come to visit as well, with Roy giving Hikaru a model biplane as a gift. Hikaru is still kind of down from both not seeing Minmay and his insecurities regarding his feelings for her post-dream and thus isn’t in the mood for Kakizaki’s lighthearted banter. Dragging Kakizaki out, Roy says that he’ll see him later. Before he leaves, Max in what seemed innocent but I can only view as a keikaku doori move, asks if Minmay brought the flowers and then realizes out loud that Misa brought them.
Who wears short shorts skirts?
Enough to cheer anyone up.
Misa: proto-tsundere.
Max, you sly shipper you.
Meanwhile Roy meets with Claudia to try and find Minmay to tell her to visit Hikaru and cheer him up.
In the civilian area of the ship a new Minmay doll has been put on sale, and the Genshiken Team decides that they need to start their figure collection somewhere and steals one as children mob the stand. Ducking around a corner, they’re run into by Vanessa, Kim, and Shammy who are debating whether to go to a disco or not. The Zentradi try to hide their loot, but Shammy’s gaze pierces cloud, shadow, earth, and flesh and she soon accuses Loli of being a lolicon, but for some reason she finds this endearing instead of repulsive and the three bridge bunnies drag the Genshiken Team off to dance. Meanwhile Millia and Kamjin are having a little argument, where Kamjin informs her of the formidable ace onboard the Macross, piquing her interest enough to plan an attack to lure him out. Onboard the Macross Roy finds Minmay and asks her to visit Hikaru, while gracefully ignores another of Kaifun’s asinine, disrespectful, and insensitive remarks.
Did they make a Lucky Star-Macross hybrid out of this one too?
Just because he liked Kanamemo doesn’t mean you should make assumptions…well, maybe you can.
Several actually, but only one Blue Baron.
“So take a break to help out the guy who nearly died, yeesh.”
Yes, militaries exist to start wars for the hell of it. Jackass.
Millia’s ship descends into Earth’s atmosphere to launch at fighter sweep against the Macross and to lure out Max so Millia can engage in some ace combat. Valkyries are scrambled and the battle is joined. Soon Millia picks out Max from the other UN fighters and the first of what will likely be many awesome dogfights begins.
Foe yay? I hope so. They would make an unstoppable pair of aces.
Nice split screen thruster/throttle shot.
The duel continues.
Misa’s back in top form, noticing the pattern before anyone else.
As the battle continues outside Minmay finally comes by to visit Hikaru, mostly talking about herself and how busy she is. Hikaru gives voice to his uncertainty about the future of their relationship, but Minmay passes out on his bed from too many days of only two hours of sleep. Outside the duel between Max and Millia goes on as Roy attempts to hold off the rest of the Zentradi, taking some hits in the process. Millia then makes a run for the Macross, hoping to gain an advantage against Max inside the ship. But this proves to be a mistake, as Max chases her inside and nearly downs her Queadluun before she escapes from the ship and retreats, heavily damaged.
I didn’t realize it was Christmas already.
The beginning of the end for Minmay?
Roy keeps the numerous regulars busy…
While Max holds his own against the Zentradi’s finest ace.
Flying into the Macross, Millia is hoping the terrain will work to her advantage, despite piloting a larger craft.
Bang bang, he shot her down.
After Millia and the Zentradi forces retreat Minmay is awoken in the hospital room by her manager, Hikaru having tried to make it to a hangar when he heard the fighting going on inside the ship. The manager forcibly pulls her along to get back to the movie set while she wonders where Hikaru is. Roy meanwhile is sitting in his quarters strumming his guitar while Claudia prepares the pineapple salad she promised. But then, as it’s ready to be served, he falls forward, bleeding from three wounds in his back sustained during the battle. Instead of being treated when he knew he was done for, he chose to spend his last moments with his beloved Claudia. So passes Roy Fokker, ace pilot of both the Unification Wars and the Earth-Zentradi Conflict. His GARtyrdom for love and shipmates is a shining example to the rest of the UN Spacy.
Too bad he’s just a jerk instead of deliciously evil like Grace O’Connor.
Going out in style.
He died as he lived: bound by duty and compassionate to those around him.
Breaking the news.
A moment of tribute to Capt. Roy Fokker, UNS.
Roy Fokker: ace pilot, caring superior, lech, faithful comrade, and love of Claudia. 1980-2009.
Final Thoughts: – I knew the pineapple salad thing meant something bad before I started out watching the series. Now I see its significance.
- Despite the downer ending, there was plenty to be happy about during these episodes. Minmay appears to be on the out, and Misa in ascendance.
- Furthermore we got to see a great dogfight between Max and Millia, and I’m hoping this leads to some long term rivalry and/or foe yay.
- The Macross Frontier troll with the pineapple cake is now clear to me.
- Much glory to Misa for getting over her ex-boyfriend/Kaifun confusion so quickly!
- The recap episode is a great example of how a recap episode can be done well (if the writers insist on having one in the first place.) I really, really liked how Hikaru skipped through various altered memories to come to his realization.
- There’s something inherently unfortunate about pineapples. You’ve got Pineapple Salad here, and Officer 223 pining (pun not originally intended but I wish it was) over his ex-girlfriend by keeping around cans of her favorite pineapple that expire on her birthday in Chungking Express (my favorite movie EVAR.)
- Poor Claudia


















































13 Comments
Ah, Pineapple Salad…one of the best episodes in the series, which inspired one of the best episodes of Frontier. Focker is one of the greatest characters in Macross, and truly, “Ye c’n still fight when yer drunk!”
It’s pretty much all awesome (from a story standpoint) for the next clutch of episodes, although the animation gets utterly terrible in a few episodes.
(And Chungking Express is one of my all-time favorites as well.)
Oh, and you can read “My Fair Minmay” without fear of spoilers. It only covers episodes 8 to 12 and doesn’t refer to anything past those episodes.
Wah! I know they had to kill him, so that he could make way for Hikaru being the veteran, but Roy Fokker really was a class of his own. I’d wish we’d get more pilots like him ( in more Macross series ).
ROY!!!!!
There goes one of the most GAR characters of anime. T_T
As a kid this was really one of saddest moments for me in SDFM.
Awesome dogfight though between Max and Millia.
“Furthermore we got to see a great dogfight between Max and Millia, and I’m hoping this leads to some long term rivalry and/or foe yay.”
You’re in for a surprise.
I’ll give you that.
“You’re in for a surprise.
I’ll give you that.
”
don’t say that, now he knows those two will have a decisive cooking contest on which the face of the galaxy depends upon.
Too bad that episode had some of the greatest QUALITY animation in the entire series.
Roy!!!!!!!
That episode was one of the saddest moments of TV when I was a kid.
Reading this post made me aware of some factual errors I’ve made regarding Hikaru in the hospital. I did not remember how Minmay was taken away from the room by her handlers; and how it was Misa who brought him the sad news.
This is some kind of turning point in the triangle; a refrain of which occured in Macross Frontier episodes 11-13 wherein Sheryl becomes the one stuck in a hospital bed and Ranka’s star is in its ascendancy.
@ Yot-chan
I got a HUEG post re the good work you did on ‘My Fair Minmay’ Watch out for it! ^_^
In the mean time, remember some love boys:
http://ghostlightning.wordpress.com/2009/10/17/oh-macross-its-just-a-popular-song-of-course-it-was-a-love-song-do-you-remember-love/
@ Yot-chan
Excellent, I’ll start reading it in the next day or two. Thanks.
“And Chungking Express is one of my all-time favorites as well.” Good man. Story, visual technique, music, themes, it has them all. I’m a big fan of Wang Kar Wai’s films in general, with In the Mood for Love being my second favorite of his.
@ Magnus
He reminded me a lot of Mu La Frage from Gundam SEED (though I guess it’s the other way around given the chronological order.) They always seem to die.
@ grss1982 and random passing dude
I have a feeling about those two. And this being Macross, where songs can jam or energize a whole fleet of Vajra, I wouldn’t put it past them to have a cooking competition
@ Lanis
I actually rarely notice QUALITY in newer series, and the dating of Macross has kind of made me immune to it while watching this. Thankfully it didn’t affect my enjoyment of the episodes.
@ Epi
Oh man, I wouldn’t have wanted to watch Roy die when I was a little kid.
@ ghostlightning
I’m highly considering re-watching Frontier once this is all over. I remember some references and trolls now, but I completely forgot about the timing of Sheryl being in the hospital while Ranka’s fame took off.
Late reply since I keep getting blocked (home internet provider is apparently behind a proxy or something).
An interesting Frontier link is that it’s the womanizer’s who bite the dust, regardless of fruit dish. Actually, I’ve realized that in relation to the male leads, Roy and Michel actually do have alot in common. Both are the sempai to the male lead in an aerobatic troupe (or at least, Roy was before he quit to join the military) and both are the ones who are taking an interest in the love life of the male lead (whereas Ozma, who is the assumed Roy analogue, doesn’t really care about Alto’s personal life).
Actually..
From what I remember watching Macross Frontier.. I remember seeing Klan feeding Michael (Or however you spell his name) something that looked suspiciously like Apples or Pineapples… in the background shortly after Ozma had his scare.
@ d3v
You might be right about that pattern. If I can get my hands on the other Macross series sometime and watch them I’ll have to try and confirm this.
@ Vhen
Your comment is one of many that is really making me want to re-watch Frontier to try and pick up on all these things. That would be pretty funny if they trolled the viewers with the pineapple cake and then had the infamous fruit appearing in the background with the guy who will actually get killed.
The more womanizing character doesn’t bite the dust in Macross Plus, but then it’s an OVA/movie rather than a full series so maybe it doesn’t count. I don’t know about Macross 7 or Macross Zero.
@Keith: The womanizing character in Macross Zero doesn’t bite the dust as well.